Outdoor & Garden · Single tool · DIY
Pick Mattock: The Digging Tool for Ground a Shovel Cannot Break
Our verdict
Estwing 5-Pound Pick Mattock, 36-Inch Fiberglass Handle
8.3/10
Worth-owning score
Price tier Mid ($$)
View on AmazonOur own score from specs, buyer reviews and tests. Not a customer rating. Photo from the Amazon listing.
Quick answer
A pick mattock is a heavy digging tool with a pick on one side and a flat chopping blade (an adze) on the other. It breaks up hard clay, packed gravel and tough roots so a shovel can move the soil. Buy one if you dig post holes, garden beds or trenches in difficult ground.
What is a pick mattock?
A pick mattock is a long-handled digging tool with a heavy steel head. One side of the head ends in a point, called the pick. The other side is a flat, wide blade set at a right angle to the handle like a short hoe. Some makers call it an adze, others a hoe end. You swing it like an axe, and the head does the work.
The pick side breaks hard ground. It concentrates all the weight and speed of the swing into a small point, which cracks packed clay, loosens gravel and works between rocks. The blade side chops through roots, scrapes loosened soil and cuts a clean trench wall.
You may hear it called a pick, a grub hoe, a cutter mattock or a garden mattock. A true cutter mattock has an axe-like blade on one side instead of a pick. A pick mattock, which is the one we cover here, has the pick.
Gardeners and landscapers reach for one when a shovel will not go in. Forum threads about mattocks mention the same jobs again and again: trenching for drain tile and pipe, breaking rocky soil, digging out root balls and setting posts.
Why you'll want it
The pitch is simple: it keeps your shovel from becoming a very expensive pry bar.
Dig where a shovel will not. Anyone who has stood on a shovel only to feel it bounce knows the problem. Dry clay can be nearly as hard as concrete, and gravel mixed with clay is worse. A mattock breaks that ground so the shovel can lift it. Easy Digging's guide to rocky and rooty soil recommends exactly this: use the pick mattock first to break up roughly the top nine inches, then scoop out the loosened soil.
Cut roots without a saw. The flat blade slices through small and medium roots in a few swings. Pulling an old shrub or clearing a fence line becomes a manageable job.
Save your back. A good swing uses the weight of the head, not your arms. You still work, but you spend your energy where it counts, and your shovel stays intact.
One tool, three jobs. Break, chop and scrape. That makes a mattock a strong choice if you want a single tool for yard work in rough ground.
Own it once, use it for years. A forged steel head and a good handle can last decades with basic care. Replacement heads are sold separately for this model, according to the listing, so a broken handle does not mean a new tool.
Where you will use it
- Setting posts: fence, mailbox and deck posts in hard or rocky ground. A fence calculator helps you plan how many posts and holes you need.
- New garden beds: breaking sod and packed soil before you amend it.
- Trenches: irrigation lines, drain pipes and low-voltage cable runs.
- Stump and root work: exposing and cutting roots before pulling a stump.
- Land clearing: old brush, thorny shrubs and tough weeds with deep roots.
- Landscaping edges: chopping a clean edge along a path or patio.
For post holes you plan to fill with concrete, a concrete calculator tells you how much mix each hole needs.
Mattock, shovel, digging bar: which one when
People often ask whether they need a mattock or a digging bar. They overlap, but they are not the same.
- Shovel: moves loose soil. It is the finishing tool for any hole, and it is not meant to break hard ground.
- Digging bar (also called a tamping bar): a long steel rod with a chisel end. It is excellent for punching narrow, deep holes and loosening rocky subsoil, but it is slow for wide trenches or beds. Easy Digging warns against prying with a digging bar because it can bend. Use a mattock or a pinch bar for prying.
- Pick mattock: breaks a wide area of hard soil and cuts roots in the same pass. For most homeowners with clay, it is the most versatile of the three.
If your soil is soft, a shovel is enough. If you hit rocks all day, add a digging bar. If you fight clay and roots, buy the mattock first. If roots are the bigger problem than rocks, a cutter mattock, with its axe-style blade, may suit you better than a pick mattock.
What buyers and testers say about the Estwing 5-pound pick mattock
We read the customer-review summary on the Amazon listing, the maker's description, forum threads from gardeners and tradespeople, and video reviews of mattocks.
According to the listing's review summary, buyers describe the Estwing as a high-quality tool that holds up well over time, and one buyer said it worked great for breaking through dried clay. The listing describes a drop-forged, heat-treated steel head and a double-injected fiberglass handle, and says replacement heads are sold separately.
Mattock forum threads on Garage Journal point to a few patterns that apply to any model. Members prefer the pick mattock for general digging, tend to like fiberglass handles because wood needs refinishing, and say heavier heads do more work but wear you out sooner. Common complaints are lighter or cheaper models bending, edges that are dull out of the box, and fatigue from swinging a heavy head all day.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Strong build. The listing describes a drop-forged, heat-treated head, and buyers say it holds up. | Heavy. A 5-pound head is tiring over a long session, so pace yourself. |
| Good reach. The 36-inch handle keeps your body upright and gives leverage. | Overkill for soft soil. A shovel does the job in loose dirt. |
| Weather-resistant handle. Fiberglass does not rot or dry out like wood, and forum members say it needs less upkeep. | Needs storage space. It is long and heavy, so it needs a wall hook or a corner of the shed. |
| Replaceable head. Replacement heads are sold separately, per the listing. | Edges may need touching up. Forum members mention dull edges on some mattocks, so keep a file handy. |
| Breaks hard ground. Buyers report good results on dried clay and rocky soil. | Overstrikes can hurt the handle. Missing the target and hitting a rock with the shaft can damage any handle, fiberglass or wood. |
Who it's for
- Homeowners setting fence or deck posts in clay or rocky ground
- Gardeners breaking new beds in packed soil or clearing roots
- Trench diggers running irrigation, drain or cable lines
- Anyone clearing old stumps and brush from a yard or lot
Who should skip it
- People who only dig in loose garden soil. A regular shovel is enough, and lighter.
- Anyone who cannot swing a heavy tool safely. A mattock demands strength, balance and care.
- Those with tiny storage space. It is long and heavy, and it needs a spot in the garage or shed.
How to use it
Safety first: a mattock is heavy and sharp. Give yourself room, wear the right gear and work at a steady pace.
- Check the tool. Make sure the head is tight on the handle, the handle has no cracks, and the edges are clean. Do not use a loose head.
- Gear up. Wear safety glasses, sturdy boots (steel toe if you have them) and work gloves. Long pants help with flying chips of soil and stone.
- Call before you dig. Before you dig anywhere new, call your local utility locating service so you do not hit a buried gas, water, electric or communications line. In the United States, dial 811. It is free.
- Clear the area. Make sure no one is within a full swing's reach, including kids and pets. Look up for branches and wires.
- Set your stance. Stand with your feet about shoulder-width apart and your knees slightly bent. Keep your feet out of the swing path.
- Grip the handle. Put one hand near the end and the other a bit lower, as you would on an axe. Let the lower hand slide as you swing.
- Swing with the head, not your arms. Lift the mattock, let it fall with your body weight, and guide it to the spot. Let gravity do most of the work. Aim for the same spot a few times to crack the ground.
- Pry, do not just pound. After the point sinks in, pull the handle toward you to lever the soil loose. This breaks more ground than repeated chopping.
- Switch to the flat blade. Flip the tool to chop through roots or to pull the broken soil toward you.
- Shovel out the loose material. Scoop the broken ground out, then repeat the break-and-clear cycle until you reach the depth you need.
- Take breaks and stay hydrated. Digging in hard ground tires you faster than you think. Stop before your form gets sloppy.
- Clean and store it. Wipe off soil, dry the head and hang it up off the floor. A light coat of oil on the steel helps prevent rust.
Tips for easier digging
- Wet the ground first. A slow soak the night before softens clay and makes every swing more productive.
- Work in layers. Break and remove a few inches at a time rather than trying to dig a deep hole in one go.
- Dig a test hole. Easy Digging suggests a small test hole first to find rocks and roots before you pick tools or plan the layout.
- Mind rocks. If the point rings on a stone, stop. Use the pick to work around it, and pry it out instead of hammering it.
- Keep a flat file handy. A quick pass on the pick and the blade keeps them biting.
- Do not use the handle as a hammer. Strike with the head only.
Common mistakes
- Swinging from the arms alone. You will tire in minutes. Let the head fall and guide it, and use your legs and hips to lift.
- Overstriking. If you miss the spot and the handle hits a rock or a hard edge, the handle can crack. Slow down and aim.
- Digging without checking for lines. Buried utilities are a real danger. Call 811 first, every time, even for a shallow hole.
- Working in a crowd. Keep children, pets and helpers well outside your swing, and never hand the tool to someone standing close.
- Leaving it outside. Rain and sun age handles and rust heads. Store it in a shed or garage.
- Forcing a stuck head. If the point wedges in a crack, rock the handle sideways and back. Do not twist it hard, which can loosen the head.
What to look for when buying
You do not need to be an expert to pick a good mattock. A few simple checks will do it.
Head material and forging. Look for a forged, heat-treated steel head. A forged head is stronger than a cast one and holds an edge. This is where cheap tools cut corners, so it is worth a closer look at the description.
Weight. Head weights vary. Forum members often suggest a head in the range of about 2.5 to 5 pounds for real work, and note that the heaviest tools tire you out. If you are not used to heavy tools, a mid-weight head is a good place to start. If you are digging in heavy clay or rocky soil, a heavier head is worth considering.
Handle. Fiberglass handles resist weather and are tough. Wood handles are traditional, and they feel good in the hand, but they can break when overstruck. Pay attention to the length too. A longer handle swings harder; a shorter one is easier in tight spots.
Grip. A cushioned or textured grip reduces shock and blisters. It also helps when your hands sweat.
Attachment. The head should be mounted solidly. If it wiggles in the store or on arrival, send it back.
Edge quality. The pick should be pointed and the blade should have a clean edge. A dull tool wastes your effort.
Tier. A budget mattock does the job on soft ground and occasional use. Mid-range tools use better steel and handles for regular yard work. Pro models are built for daily abuse on big sites.
The table below sums up the main specs so you can compare models side by side.
Key specs to look for
| Spec | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Head weight | Heavier heads (around 5 pounds) break ground with less effort; lighter heads are easier to swing all day. Pick for your strength and the soil. |
| Head material | Forged steel, heat-treated. Avoid cast heads that can crack when they hit a rock. |
| Handle material | Fiberglass resists snapping and weather. Hardwood feels classic and absorbs shock, but can break if it is overstruck. |
| Handle length | A longer handle gives more leverage. Shorter handles are better in tight spaces or for smaller users. |
| Grip | A textured or cushioned grip that does not slip when your hands are sweaty or wet. |
| Head attachment | The head should be firmly attached. Look for a design that keeps it from flying off, and check it before each use. |
| Blade shape | A sharp, pointed pick end and an adze with a clean edge. Dull edges slow you down and tire you out. |
Where to get it
For this guide we're featuring the Estwing 5-pound pick mattock with a 36-inch fiberglass handle. According to the product listing, it has a drop-forged, heat-treated steel head and a double-injected fiberglass handle, is meant for breaking hard ground and hoeing in rocky soil, and is made in India. Estwing has a long reputation for solid forged tools. We chose it because it balances weight, reach and build for a homeowner who digs often.
Estwing 5-Pound Pick Mattock, 36-Inch Fiberglass Handle
- Breaks hard clay, rocky soil and roots that stop a shovel cold
- Drop-forged steel head and fiberglass handle, per the listing
- One tool with a pick for breaking and an adze for chopping and trenching
How we scored it
Usefulness 8/10 · Value 8/10 · Durability 9/10. This is our own opinion, based on specs, buyer reviews and independent tests. It is not an Amazon or customer rating.
Check the current listing and read the latest reviews before you decide. If you think a lighter or heavier head fits you better, use the spec list above to compare options.
Once you have a mattock, pair it with a laser distance meter for laying out post holes, and keep a solid pliers set handy for fence wire and hardware.
Watch and read more
Video reviews
- What is a Mattock? Adam Greenman what a Mattock is and how to use a mattock — Greenman Garden Tools
A short demo from a garden-tool seller showing a mattock chopping through compacted, stony soil and brambles. It is a sales-style clip, not an independent test. - Mattock General Usages, How To Use It, Sharpen Tips and What Makes It Different From a Pick Axe — Hooked On Tool
Explains what a mattock is for, why to use it gently with a chopping motion, how to sharpen it with a file, and how it differs from a pickaxe. It demonstrates a one-sided mattock, not the pick-and-adze head, so treat it as a general guide.
Free calculators
FigureMyHome
- Fence Calculator — Plan posts, rails and holes before you start digging.
- Concrete Calculator — Work out how much mix your post holes need.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a pick mattock and a regular pickaxe?
A pickaxe has a pointed pick on both ends. A pick mattock has a pick on one end and a flat adze blade on the other. The adze cuts roots and scrapes soil, which makes the mattock more versatile for yard work.
Do I still need a shovel?
Yes. The mattock breaks and loosens the ground, and a shovel scoops it out. Used together, they dig hard ground much faster than either one alone.
How heavy should a pick mattock be?
Most homeowners are comfortable with a mid-weight head. A heavier head does more work per swing, but wears you out sooner. If you are unsure, choose the weight you can swing for a full minute without strain.
Is a fiberglass handle better than wood?
Fiberglass handles tend to resist breaking and weather better, and they need no upkeep. Wood handles feel good and can be replaced easily, but they can split if you miss a swing and strike the handle on a rock.
Can I use a pick mattock to break concrete?
Not as a main tool. It will chip old, weak concrete or asphalt edges, but a sledgehammer, a breaker bar or a rented demolition hammer is safer and faster for real concrete work.
How do I keep it sharp?
Use a flat file on the pick point and the adze edge now and then, and wear gloves and eye protection when you do. Wipe the head dry after use and store it out of the rain.




